Anthelios Clear Skin Dry Touch SPF 60
Every morningBuilt for skin that goes shiny. Matte finish, oil absorbing, no dewy look.

Photo: Open Beauty Facts, CC BY-SA 3.0
The one to start with. No white cast, no heavy feel, and the only sunscreen on this list that behaves in a beard.
Anyone starting sunscreen at all, and anyone with a beard. The texture is thin enough to work into facial hair without leaving white streaks at the roots.
You want a matte finish. This one leaves the skin slightly dewy, which reads as shiny if you are oily by lunchtime anyway.
It solves the two reasons men give up on sunscreen: the white cast and the heavy feel. A sunscreen you actually put on every morning beats a technically better one sitting unused in a drawer.
If you buy one thing from this entire site, buy a sunscreen, and this is the easiest one to actually keep using. Sun exposure is a major factor in premature skin ageing, and a broad spectrum sunscreen used properly is one of the few products in this category with solid evidence behind it. The reason most men do not use it is not price, it is the white residue and the heavy feel. This one is light, disappears on most skin tones, and is less likely to leave white streaks in facial hair than the thicker options here.
Slightly dewy finish, so if you want a matte look, take the Anthelios Clear Skin instead. And no sunscreen replaces shade at midday.
Every morning, last step before you leave. Roughly two fingers worth for face and neck, which is more than feels natural and is where nearly everyone falls short. Reapply if you are outside for hours.
Modern chemical filters at SPF 50+ with PA++++. The texture is what sets it apart, not the protection level.
For a matte finish, the La Roche-Posay Anthelios Clear Skin. If chemical filters have stung your skin before, the EltaMD UV Clear.
Built for skin that goes shiny. Matte finish, oil absorbing, no dewy look.
Expensive, and worth a look if your skin has reacted to other sunscreens.
Mineral filters plus a tint. The combination that solves both the stinging and the white cast at once.